Cane for Stock Whips

Cane for Stock Whips

So if you’ve been following my little blog you’ve noticed that recently I’ve been expanding from bullwhips to also include stock whips.  I’ve always made more than just bullwhips it’s just that I’ve been focusing a bit on really learning more about stock whips lately.  One thing that makes a stock whip a  stock whip is the stock of course.  In Australia it seems that most whip makers use Toheti Cane for the stock and that is also true for most  whip makers in the USA.  The makers in the USA import it from Australia.

I’d thought about using Rattan Cane for stock whip handles in the past, but never really did much investigation.  Recently Jeff Roseborough turned me onto a website that sells 24 inch Rattan Cane lengths for $2.10 – $3.15 each (depending on quantity).  These are a tad long for stock whip handle with most stock whip handles being in the 20 – 21 inch range, but could be any length.

I picked  up a few of these to try them out.  In fact I used Rattan Cane for this stock whip:

Stock whip

The main difference I notice between Rattan Cane and Toheti Cane is that Rattan seem to have just a bit more flex to it than Toheti Cane.  Also after looking at both I suspect that both types of cane might be the same thing grown in different places so have different names or are very closely related in the vine family.

Here’s a visual side by side comparison of the Toheti and Rattan Canes:

Stock whip

Another thing I notice is that the Rattan Cane was much easier to shape the keeper end than the Toheti Cane was.  I think that’s because the Toheti Cane is a bit more dense which is also probably why it’s has less flex to it.

The skin on the Toheti Cane also a bit harder.  However having a firmer skin doesn’t really matter much, I think the Toheti Cane’s skin might repel moisture a bit better, but that’s just a guess.

Another factor is price.  Rattan Cane much more easily available in the USA than Toheti Cane is. Rattan Cane at retail is $3.15 and Toheti at retail $4.95 or about $1.80 more.  But then you have to figure in shipping with one coming from the USA and one  from Australia.  The shipping on the Toheti Cane is about double the Rattan Cane.

What all that means to the end product of the stock whip…not much.  Because both types of cane are natural products and no two will be exactly the same you’ll probably find some Rattan Cane with the same or less flex than Toheti Cane.  For me I think I’m going to use the Rattan Cane for yard whips (cowhide leather stock whips) and the Toheti Cane for nicer kangaroo stock whips.  Going with a Toheti Cane handle for the price of a kangaroo stock whip is a drop in the bucket where on  a cheaper whip it makes a bit more difference in the margin.

Maybe I’ll offer a choice on cheaper yard whips where someone could upgrade to a Toheti Cane handle from the Rattan Cane for an extra few bucks.

Louie
http://bullwhips.org

4 thoughts on “Cane for Stock Whips

  1. So overall you were satisfied with the quality of the rattan cane?

    I think I’ll buy a couple of them for my first few stockwhips. When you decide to get some toheti

    from australia ( you mentioned murphy’s but Paul Nolan told me he bought a ton of them from

    Richard Taubman a few years back, so might want to look into that ) as long as I’m not broke

    at the time I would like to go in on some, if you would let me.

    1. I think that the Toheti is a better cane overall. The Rattan isn’t bad for what it is. Would I use Rattan on a kangaroo stock whip? Nope. However I bet there is someone that likes a bit more flex in their whip handles and would prefer the Rattan, that person is not me.

  2. Oh G-d! I hadn’t seen this post of yours. I’ve just written about Tohiti and Rattan. Still I think the good part is that I show how you can make a nicely tapered rattan cane handle. It is a bit more work, but I think it’s worth it. If you have the time, I’d love to know your opinion, Louie.

    1. I love that we both came to the same conclusion that there’s not much difference between Rattan and Toheti Cane. Once you clean it up especially for a crop it look great! I’ve never used cane for a crop’s core, well that not 100% true, I use the rawhide cores from David Morgan and they have a cane center.

      In the past I wasn’t the biggest fan of half plait handles on kangaroo stock whips…but it’s been slowly growing on me over the years. I’m starting to like the look of the naturalness of the them with the little imperfections like small bends etc.

      Louie

Leave a Reply